Hall of Fame
Creech was the 1990 Mid-American Soccer Conference Player of the Year and was a three-time all conference selection for the Red and White in 1990, 1991 and 1993. He also captured All-Ohio honors in 1990, '91 and '93, while earning NSCAA All-Mideast Region honors in 1993. Creech placed his name on three Miami career charts, ranking third in career goals (31), fourth in career assists (19) and fourth in career points (81) at that time. He also ranked on three single-single season lists, tying for third in goals (14 in 1990), tying for third in points (31 in 1990) and tying for 10th in assists (7 in 1990).